Document Type : Research Paper
Authors
Abstract
Objectives: The “MEHR” housing project is one of the most recent projects undertaken by the Ministry of Roads & Urban Development. Despite the main aim of the project which is accommodating low income citizens, recent studies demonstrate that the living condition in these housing projects is not satisfactory. The main aim of this article is to evaluate the satisfaction level of residents in Mehr housing project from residents’ perspectives through both qualitative and quantitative methods. “Exploratory Factor analysis” was used as the main method mainly due to its capability in analyzing the parameters which are affected by the context.
Findings: The findings of this article indicate that factor analysis causes a reduction in the number of satisfaction indicators from 71 to 22. Furthermore, application of “varimax rotation” in factor analysis method is due to its ability in correlating literature reviews with the result. In this article, KMO index was 0/611 which is considered in the standard range of factor analysis. Skewness & Kurtosis indexes was calculated to assess the normality of questionnaire data. Finally, normalization process show the various conditions of various factors. Eventually, cluster analysis presented the distribution of satisfaction in the study sample (150 households). In contrast to prior studies, this research identified a four-level structure for Mehr housing project satisfactory factors (housing units, housing buildings; housing site, surrounding area of the site)
Results: The results show that the most important factors in the residents’ dissatisfaction in “MEHR” housing project were the lack of access to primary civic services (educational, religious and security), lack of activity centers, the need for pedestrian-oriented and mixed use development, insufficient surveillance and low maintenance service on the interior spaces of housing units, high level of environmental pollutants and lack of recreational spaces. The findings of this article show that 76 percent of households were not satisfied with the quality of their life. The result of this article would help the executive agencies of “MEHR” housing projects, in considering the satisfaction level of residents. This article also demonstrates that "shelter making" alone cannot be considered a comprehensive satisfactory parameter for low income households because the essential needs of individuals is to live in a well-designed community and not just in a shelter. Therefore, this article recommends to first assess the future needs of residents prior to the development process. People who live in Dehaqan Mehr housing were found to be satisfied with having a shelter but the quality of life was not acceptable due to the factors discussed. The main factors causing serious problems in this Mehr housing project were identified to be related to its infrastructures and social and health issues as Finally, it is worth mentioning that the city management system of “MEHR” housing project has to invest on short term actions, first to build a school, a mosque and a police station and second to allocate the best places for communal activities (such as markets, green spaces and cultural centers).
Keywords
- Social housing
- Mehr housing project
- residential satisfaction
- Exploratory Factor Analysis
- Mehr housing in Dehaqan
Main Subjects
- Abdul Mohit, M & Azim, M., (2012). Assessment of Residential Satisfaction with Public Housing in Hulhumale, Maldives. Social and Behavioral Sciences, vol 50, PP.756 – 770.
- Amin salehi, F., (2008). Promoting quality of housing environments in high-level housing sites and giving approperiate gidelines, a case study of Ekbatan town. M.A thesis, Tarbyat Modares University. [In Persian]
- Azizi, M.M & Araste, M., (2011). An analysis of housing satisfaction in Yazd, Yazd provision, Iran. Name nenari & sharsazi journal. No.8, PP 111-129. [In Persian]
- Barton, H & Grant, M. & Guise, R., (2003). Shaping Neighborhoods: A guide for health, Sustainability and Vitality, Spon Press, London and New York.
- Choudhury, I., (2005). A Conceptual Model of Resident Satisfaction with Reference to Neighborhood Composition. World Congress on Housing: Transforming Housing Environments through Design, Winter,PP 27-30.Pretoria, South Africa
- Cozens, P. & Hiller, D. & Prescott G., (2001). Crime and the Designresidential Property–Exploring the Theoretical Background, Journal of Property Management, Vol. 19, Issue 2, PP. 136-164.
- Crowe, T., (2003). Advanced Crime Prevention through Environmental Design, (Seminar notes), American Crime Prevention Institute, Louisville, Kentucky, PP. 33-67.
- Dallalpour, M.R., (1998).an evaluation of low income urban housing policy in Iran department of city, and regional planning, papers in planning research, No.169.CARDIFF University.
- Dallalpour, M.R, (2000). House planning, Samt publication, 1st time. [In Persian]
- Dehkhoda, A.A., (1955).Dehkhoda dictionary, University of Tehran publication. [In Persian]
- Dekker, K & Sako, M & Ronald V., (2007). Explaining defferentials in housing and neighbourhood satisfaction in larg housing states in European cities .sustainable urban area, international conference, Rotterdam.
- Duany, A & Speck, J & Lydon, M., (2009). The Smart Growth Manual, United States: McGraw-Hill.
- F.Kain, J & Quigley, M (1970). Measuring the value of housing quality, journal of statistical association, volume 65, and issue 330.
- Francescato, G & Weidemann, S. & Anderson, J.R, (1987), Residential satisfaction: Its uses and limitations in housing research in Housing and neighbourhoods: Theoritical and Empirical contributions. Vliet, W.V., Choldin, H., Michelson, W., and Popenoe, D. (Eds), Westport, Connecticut: Greenwood Press.
- Iman, M.T & Kaveh, M., (2012). Assessing the level of quality of life in “Mehr” housing project of Fuladshahr, Isfahan provision in Iran. Motale jame shenakhti shahri journal, No.6, p 1-33. [In Persian]
- Kaiser, H.F., (1960). The Application of Electronic Computers to Factor Analysis. Educational and Psychological Measurement, Vol 20, PP. 141–151.
- Kawakami N, & Winkleby, M & Skog, L & Szulkin, R, & Sundquist K., (2011). Differences in Neighborhood Accessibility to Health-related Resources: A Nationwide Comparison between Deprived and Affluent Neighborhoods in Sweden, Journal of Health & Place 17, PP. 132–139.
- Knapp, E., (1982). Housing Problems in the Third World: Theoretical Terms of Reference, Methodology, and Four Case Studies in Bogota, Jakarta, Nairobi and Kasama, University of Stuttgart.
- Lau, Joseph C.Y & Chiu, Catherine C.H. (2004). Accessibility of Workers in a Compact City: the Case of HongKong", Journal of Habitat International, Vol. 28, PP. 89–102.
- Laughlin, L & Danielle, F (2005).Gender and neighbourhood satisfication”.temple University, policy research conference.
- Lotfi, S & Koohsari, M.J., (2009). Analyzing Accessibility Dimension of Urban Qualityof Life: Where Urban Designers Face Duality Between Subjective and Objective Reading of Place, Journal of Social Indicator Research, Vol. 94, PP. 417–435.
- Maleki, l (2012). Promoting environment quality in city neighborhoods through sustainable development approach, a case study of Chizar nighberhood, M.A thesis, Art University of Tehran. [In Persian]
- Ministry of Roads & Urban Development website: http://www.mrud.ir/Portal/Home
- Moein, M (1984). Moein dictionary. Amirkabir university publication. [In Persian]
- Nastaran, M & Ranaei, A., (2010). An analysis on the participation and coworking in preparing lands projects of Mehr housing. Armanshahr journal, no.123, p4-11. [In Persian]
- Olaru, D & Smith, B & Taplin, John H.E., (2011). Residential Location and Transit-oriented Development in a New Rail Corridor, Journal of Transportation Research Part A, No. 45, PP. 219–237.
- Parhizgar, A & Shahedi, N., (2010). A review on Mehr housing project in cities with less than 25000 population, Abadi journal, No. 55, p 44-69. [In Persian]
- Qasemi esfahani, M (2004). Where we from? : Giving identity to housing zone, Rowzane publication, [In Persian].
- Rafeian, M, Asgari, A & Asgari zadeh, Z., (2009). Resident’s satisfaction from urban housing environments, olum mohiti journal, no.1, p57-68. [In Persian]
- Rezaei, M.R & Komaei zade, Y., (2012). Evaluating quality of life among resident in Mehr housing projects, A case study of Fatemieh housing site in Yazd, Yazd provience, Iran, Motaleat shahri journal, No.5, p13-26. [In Persian]
- Rowshan, M & shakibaei, F., (2011). Analyzing the adaptation between urban planning and resident approaches to quality of housing zones, a case study of Qazvin, Qazvin provision, Iran. 3rd confrance of urban planning and management.Spring. [In Persian]
- Shanon, G & Rashid, W & Bashshur, L., (1982). Accessibility to Medical Care among Urban American Indians in a Large Metropolitan Area", Journal of Social Science and Medicine, Vol. 16, PP.571–575.
- Sung, H & Oh, J., (2011). Transit-oriented Development in a High-density City: Identifying Its Associationwith Transit Ridership in Seoul, Korea, Cities, No. 28, PP. 70–82.
- Van pol, R., (2011). Approches and methods to assess the quality of urban housing environmens, translated by Rafeian, M & Mowludi, j. 1st time, Azarakhsh publication. [In Persian]
- Zebardast, E., (2009). Handout of Urban and regional planning methods course, M.A grade of urban planning, University of Tehran. [In Persian]
)