ISSN: 2717-4417

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Head of Interior Architecture Department, Shiraz University of Art

2 M.Sc. Student in Architecture

Abstract

Attention to the users is one of the main factors in successful architectural design. Therefore, for successful urban design with which all age groups can interact, it is necessary to know enough about each of them. For example, the mental and physical scale of children is different from adults. As a result, design requirements for them are also distinct from other age groups. However, this issue has been underestimated in today’s urban design in Iran. Accordingly, the first step to find out design principles is to identify the factors which are considered by children. In other words, their mental image should be investigated because it is the result of a two-way communication between the observer and the environment. It is through this interaction that the observer selects, organizes and gives meaning to what he/she sees. The purpose of this paper is, thus, to identify physical (elements and components) and non-physical (behaviors, events, memories) factors effective on 5-7 years old children’s mental image of Shiraz urban streetscape. It should be noted that the choice of the street is due to the fact that it is the first and most important site in people’s relationship with the city. In this research, mental images were obtained through the sketch map (children drawings) technique. The statistical population of the research consisted of 111 children selected out of 257 children aged 5 to 7 years in District 1 of Shiraz (based on field visits in 2016). A total of 118 drawings were collected by this method. In addition to descriptive analysis, they were analyzed through exploratory factor analysis in SPSS 22. Children’s drawings were examined from three dimensions in consultation with their teachers: a) in terms of drawing elements; b) in terms of color variation and the level of details drawn by the child; and finally c) the level of exaggeration in the drawing of the elements. The results indicate that sex has no meaningful correlation with the type of drawings and their content. Therefore, sex was removed as a factor of analysis. The most frequently drawn physical elements on the street (fixed and movable) are cars, street linings and traffic lights which were drawn with exaggeration in 27% of the cases. Short and tall buildings were also seen in the drawings as part of the physical elements defining the streetscape. In addition to these, the sky-related elements (e.g. cloud, sun and rain), natural elements (e.g. green space, mountains, living creatures and humans) and even events (e.g. accidents, respecting the rules, playing, etc.) were an inseparable part in children’s drawings. The streets drawn by children were without color variation or lots of detail. This could indicate lower color variation of current streets. The children in this study referred to a combination of natural elements and games as the main factor in their mental image of the street. The subsequent factors included street regulations, the sky, street structure, city landscape and intersection structure which were extracted from factor analysis.  

Keywords

Main Subjects

- Abdollahi, Mehdi; Ghasemzadeh, Behnam; Rahbaripour, Kasra (2013). The Impact of Historic Monuments Facade on the Mental Image of Citizens of Tabriz City (Case Study: Tarbiat Historic St Passage). Motaleate Shahre Irani Eslami Quarterly Journal, (11),65-71. [In Persian]
- Afrooz, Gholamali (2010). Discussions on: Psychology and training children and teenager. Tehran: Anjomane Olia va Morabian publishing. [In Persian]
- Aminzadeh, Behnaz; Daenejad, Faramarz (2002). Environmental considerations in the design and rehabilitation of urban streets. Honarhaye Ziba, (11), 50-61. [In Persian]
- Asadpour, Ali; Faizi, Mohsen; Farhang, Mozaffar; Behzadfar, Mostafa (2015). Typology of models and comparative study of methods in recording mental images and cognitive maps from the environment. Baq e Nazar Journal, (33), 13-22. [In Persian]
- Barraza, Laura (1999). Children’s drawings about the environment. Environmental Education Research, (1), 49-66.
- Catling, S.J. (1979). Maps and Cognitive Maps: The Young Child’s Perception. Geography, 64 (4), 288-296.
- Cherney, I. D., Seiwert, C. S., Dickey, T. M., & Flichtbeil, J. D. (2006). Children’s Drawings: A mirror to their minds. Educational Psychology, 26(1), 127-142.
- Downs, R. M., & Stea, D. (1973). Cognitive maps and spatial behaviours: processes and products Image and
Environment: Cognitive Mapping and Spatial Behaviour. Chicago: Aldine.
- Einarsdóttir, Jóhanna (2007). Research with children: methodological and ethical challenges. European Early Childhood Education Research Journal, 15(2), 197-211.
- Einarsdottir, Johanna, Dockett, Sue, Perry, Bob (2009) Making meaning: children’s perspectives expressed through drawings. Early Child Development and Care, 179(2), 217-232.
- Faizi, Mohsen; Asadpour, Ali (2013). Landscape Regeneration Process of Tehran Urban Squares Based on Increasing Citizens Social Interactions. Motaleate Shahri Scientific -ResearchQuarterly Journal, 2(7), 3-14. [In Persian]
- Falahat, Mohammad Sadegh; Nuhi, Samira (2012). The nature of the signs and its role in promoting the sense of space of the architecture. Honarhaye Ziba, Memari va Shahrsazi Journal, 17(1), 17-25. [In Persian]
- Groat, Linda; Wang, David (2005). Architectural Research Methods. Tehran: Tehran University publishing. [In Persian]

- Günindi, Yunus (2012). Environment in My Point of View: Analysis of the Perceptions of Environment of the Children Attending to Kindergarten through the Pictures They Draw. Social and Behavioral Science, (55), 594-603.

- Halseth, Greg & Doddridge, Joanne (2000).  Children's cognitive mapping: a potential tool for neighborhood planning. Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design, (27), 565-582.
- Heyes, Burnett & Lau, J.Y.F & Holmes, E.A (2013). Mental imagery, emotion and psychopathology across child and adolescent development. Cognitive Neuroscience, (5), 119-133.
- Kakavand, Elham; Barati, Naser; Aminzadeh Gohar Rizi, Bahram (2013). Comparative Assessment of Mental Image of Citizens with Planners to Quality of the Urban Environment (Case study: Qazvin Distressed Area). Baq e Nazar Journal, 8(26), 79-92. [In Persian]
- Kroner, Walter (2009). Architecture for Children. (Translator: Ahmad Khoshnevisi, Elmira Mir Rahimi). Tehran: Ganje Honar publishing. [In Persian]
- Lynch, Kevin (1960). The Image of the City. Massachusetts: MIT Press.
- Matthews, M.H. (1980). The Mental Maps of Children: Images of Coventry’s city center. Geography, 65(3), 169-179.
- Ministry of housing and Urban development (1995). Urban Roads Design Guidelines. Ministry of housing and Urban development publishing. [In Persian]    
- Moshtaghi, Marzieh; Allameh, Farid; Aghaei, Asghar (2011). Comparison of the concept of the child and the needs of the child from the eyes of children and parents in Isfahan. Pazhuheshgahe Olum Ensani va Motaleate Farhangi Journal, 2(2), 59-78. [In Persian]
- Obalasi, Anahita; Hoseini Nasab, Seyed Davood (2014). Study the effect of Training Montessori’s Method On Creativity Of preschoolers children aged 4 and 5 in Tabriz. Amoozesh va Arzyabi  Scientific -Research Journal, (28), 81-98. [In Persian]
- O’Craven, K.M & Kanwisher, N (2000). Mental Imagery of Faces and Places Activates Corresponding Stimulus-Specific Brain Regions. Cognitive Neuroscience, (6), 1013-1023.
- Oliverio Ferraris, Anna (2015). Children’s Drawing and its meanings. (Translator: Abdolreza Sarafan). Tehran: Dastan publishing. [In Persian]
-Oxford online Dictionaries (2016 version). Available at: http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/sign. Access in 12 May 2016.
- Pakzad, Jahanshah; Bozorg, Hamideh (2014). Environmental psychology alphabet for designers. Tehran: Armanshahr publishing. [In Persian]
- Piaget, Jean; Simon, Pierre Henri (1990). Children Psychology and Principles of Youth Education. (Translator: Enayatollah Shakibapour). Tehran: Nima publishing. [In Persian]
- Pourjafar, Mohammad Reza; Bemanian, Mohammad Reza; Taghvaei, Ali Akbar; Montazerolhojah, Mehdi (2011). An Introduction to the Physical Typology of Urban Symbols In perceptual maps of citizens(Case study: Yazd city). Nameye Memari va Shahrsazi Scientific -Research Journal, (7), 129-145. [In Persian]
- Prakasam, Antony Gnana (2013). what you should know about your child delivered by Maria Montessori. (Translator: Fariba Shahbazian). Tehran: Rahnama pubishing. [In Persian]
- Safipour, Mona; Hamili, Parvin (2012). Illustration in the book of the child and its impact on the development and creativity of the child's mind. Ketabe Mehr AnalyticalResearch Quarterly Journal, (8), 198- 209. [In Persian]
- Shakerian, Ata (2009). Comparison of family drawings for psychological analysis of children in ordinary and single-parent families. Osule Behdashte Ravani Journal, 11(4), 312-321. [In Persian]
- Soltani, Ali; Khodaparast, Bahareh (2010). Evaluation of urban streets based on a humanist approach (case study: Sommayeh St in Shiraz City). Armanshahr Scientific -Research Journal, 1(5), 97-110. [In Persian]
- Steinberg, Suzanne (2006). Maria Montessori’s Writing Method. Forum Italicum, (1), 36-60.
- Tarkashvand, Abbas; Majidi, Sahar (2013). Recognizing some signs in urban space. Anjomane Elmi Memari va Shahrsazi Iran Scientific -Research Journal, 2(6), 5-15. [In Persian]
- Thomas, Glyn; Silk, Angele M.J (2013). An introduction to the psychology of children's drawings. (Translator: Mohammad Taghi Faramarzi). Tehran: Donyaye No publishing. [In Persian]
- Wimmer, Marina; Maras, Katie; Robinson, Elizabeth; Thomas, Charlotte (2016). The format of children’s mental images: Evidence from mental scanning. Cognition, (154), 49-54.

-Günindi, Yunus (2012). Environment in My Point of View: Analysis of the Perceptions of Environment of the Children Attending to Kindergarten through the Pictures They Draw. Social and Behavioral Science, (55), 594-603.