ISSN: 2717-4417

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Associate Professor, Dept. of Geography and Urban Planning, Tabriz University, Tabriz , Iran.

2 PhD student in Geography and Urban Planning, Tabriz University, Tabriz , Iran.

3 PhD student in GIS, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.

4 Graduate of Remote Sensing and GIS, Tabriz University, Tabriz , Iran.

10.34785/J011.2021.872

Abstract

Objectives
The evolution in industry in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries led to greater human domination of the planet and the environment. In the field of clean environment, urban parks are regarded as an important element in creation of a sustainable city. They provide opportunities in various areas for instance by improving the environment quality, enabling active and passive entertainment, and creating a beautiful environment. Accordingly, thinkers have considered the strengthening of the relationship between the urban man and the nature as a major way of dealing with the problems of urbanization. Therefore, cities need particular attention today in terms of revival of the urban nature, as presence of the nature in the city, to the necessary extent, and its composition and distribution is a requirement of sustainable development. Evidence from Iran and the area under study in regard to current urban green space planning and design indicates that the idea of ​​ecological design and planning is very weakly treated. Due to the dissatisfaction with the current conditions in the design of urban green spaces as an important part of the city, development of green spaces with high ecological efficiency, significant bioclimatic features in particular, should be considered.
 
Findings
In the ranking provided by the TOPSIS method, Elogli Park exhibits the lowest positive ideal (5.41) and the highest negative ideal (13.45), followed by the Shams, Baghmishe, and Eram parks, in that order. This is because the cli coefficient, the negative ideal divided by the sum of the positive and negative ideals, for Elogli Park (15.93) is higher than those for the other parks, assigning it the highest priority in ecological terms among the parks under investigation. The four studied forest parks were classified by ecological indicators using the electric model. According to the results obtained by this method, Elogli Park was ranked first in ecological terms, and the Shams, Baghmishe, and Eram parks were ranked next. A point to be noted concerned the improper conditions of the Baghmishe and Eram parks, the latter in particular, in terms of the indicators, calling for greater attention to these parks. Based on the data on vegetation density, Shams Park exhibited denser coverage than the other parks, followed by Elogli, Baghmishe, and Eram, in that order. The denser the vegetation, the higher the priority of the park, and the better its ecological conditions. According to the three indicators studied in the GIS environment, Shams Park was in better conditions in ecological terms than the other parks.
 
Results
The results demonstrated that today’s cities need multi-purpose ecological balancing spaces rather than gardens and lawn. The prioritization of the parks based on cultural criteria indicated that the Eram and Shams parks were in better conditions than Shahgoli and Baghmishe. Physically, Elgoli Park was found to hold the highest priority, followed by Shams, Baghmishe, and Eram, in that order. In environmental terms, the Elgoli, Shams, Baghmishe, and Eram parks were ranked in that order. In terms of access features, Baghmishe and Shams were ranked first, followed by Elgoli and Eram. Finally, Elgoli and Shams were both identified through combination of the maps for all the criteria according to their weights as the best parks in terms of accessibility and cultural, environmental, and physical features. They were followed by Baghmishe Park, and Eram exhibited the lowest score among the parks in terms of the above features.

Keywords

Main Subjects

-          Ahmadi, A; Movahed, A; Shojaeian, A. (2011). Presenting the optimal model of optimal location of urban green space using GIS and AHP method (study area: District 7 of Ahvaz Municipality), Quarterly Journal of Environmental Planning, Volume 4, Number 15, pp. 147-162. [in Persian]
                                                                                                                       
-          Ismaili-Sari, A; Latifi Oskooi, N. (2006). Economic-recreational evaluation of Aoun Ibn Ali Forest Park, Tabriz, Quarterly Journal of Environmental Science and Technology, Volume 10, Number 4, pp. 208-217. [in Persian]
-          Asgharpour, M. (2006). Multi-criteria decision making, 11th edition, University of Tehran Press, Tehran. [in Persian]
-          Bahram Soltani, K. (2008). Environment, Collection of Topics and Methods of Urban Planning, Volume 2, Center for Urban Planning and Architecture Studies and Research, Shahidi Publications. [in Persian]
-          Biwarani, H; Ghofran,A. (2009).  Explaining and applying the TOPSIS multi-criteria decision-making model for ranking different urban areas in terms of crime and delinquency, Workshop Quarterly, Volume 2, Number 8, pp. 150-131. [in Persian]
-          Teymouri, R; Rustaei, Sh; Akbari Zamani, A; Ahadnejad, M. (2009). Assessment of spatial-spatial suitability of urban parks using GIS (Case study: neighborhood parks in Region 2 of Tabriz Municipality), Geographical Space Quarterly, Tenth Year, No. 30, pp. 137-168. [in Persian]
-          Hamidi, N;  Ghaybdoost, H; Ramezanian, M. (2013).  Application of network analysis methods and fuzzy TOPSIS in the analysis of the quality of electronic services in the health care sector, Health Management, Volume 17, Number 55, pp. 17-28. [in Persian]
-          Khamachi, B. (2010).  My City Tabriz, Second Edition, Tabriz, Nedaye Shams Publications.
-          Khan Sefid, M, (2011).  Principles of Urban Green Space Planning, Organization of Municipalities and Rural Affairs, Tehran. [in Persian]
-          Razzaqian, F; Rahnama, M; Tavangar, M; Aghajani, H. (2012).  "Ecological Analysis of Urban Parks (Case Study: Mashhad)", Journal of Environmental Science, Year 38, No. 4, pp. 155-168. [in Persian]
-          Rudashtian, E;  Shamkhi, A; Sharifpour, Z. (2014).  Ecological Planning of Urban Area Using the Principles of Landscape Ecology (Case Study: District 6, Keshavarz Boulevard), the Second National Conference on Planning, Conservation, Environmental Protection and Sustainable Development, Tehran. [in Persian]
-          Shanian, A. (2006).  Application of multi-criteria decision making techniques in selecting the appropriate strategy for the implementation of the IT project, Structural Management, No. 15, pp. 116-102. [in Persian]
-          Abbaszadeh, Gh; Hosseini, A. (2011).  Union of Cities, Inhabitable Cities, Benefits of Urban Environment Planning, First Edition.  Heleh Publications, Isfahan. [in Persian]
-          Alizadeh, Seyed D; Salehifard, M. (2008).  Analysis of the social and psychological dimensions of green spaces in cities (with an urban management approach), Quarterly Journal of Urban Management, Volume 6, Number 21, pp. 19-33. [in Persian]
-          Qaziunuri, S; Tabatabai, H. (2005).  Sensitivity analysis of multi-criteria decision-making issues to the technique used, Office of Presidential Technology Cooperation, Tehran. [in Persian]
-          Fazelunia, Gh; Kiani, A; Mahmoudian, H. (2011).  Location and Prioritization of Urban Parks Using Topsis Hierarchical Analysis Method and Geographic Information System (A Case Study of Aleshtar City), Quarterly Journal of Human Geography Research, No. 4, pp. 137-152. [in Persian]
-          Ghorbani, R; Teymouri,R. (2009).  An Analysis of the Role of Urban Parks in Improving the Quality of Urban Life, Case Study: Parks of Tabriz, Quarterly Journal of Human Geography Research, No. 72, pp. 47-62. [in Persian]
-          Ghorbani, R et al. (2014).  An Attitude on New Patterns of Urban Planning, First Edition, Foroozeh Publications, 224 p. [in Persian]
-          Goli, A; Zadvali Khajeh, Sh; Zadoli, Z. (2013).  Evaluation of Gender Attitude in Urban Space Design (Case Study: Shams Tabriz Women's Park), Journal of Women in Development and Politics, Volume 11, Number 2, pp. 171-188. [in Persian]
-          Larijani, M; Qasami, F; Yousefi Rubiat, E. (2013).  Ecological analysis of the green space structure of Jiroft using land use metrics, Environmental Management Quarterly, No. 25, pp. 49-64. [in Persian]
-           Leghaei, H; Hasibi, A; Fallah Farbod, Sh. (2011).  Strategies for regeneration and organization of urban parks with the aim of improving ecological and social quality (Case study: City Park located in Sangalaj neighborhood), Quarterly Journal of Natural Resources Science and Technology, Year 6, Number 3, pp. 99-114. [in Persian]
-          Movahed, S; Leghai, H; Habib, H. (2015).  Ecological park design; A step towards the environmental sustainability of cities (Case study: southwestern heights of Mashhad), Quarterly Journal of Environmental Science and Technology, Volume 18, Number 3, pp. 203-221. [in Persian]
-          Cilliers.  S & Stefan J. Siebert. 2012. Urban Ecology in Cape Town: South African Comparisons and Reflections, Biodiversity and Conservation14: 3327-3349.
-          Feizi, M. 2006. The role of urban parks in a metropolitan city, Environmental sciences 12.
-          Garcia-Melon, M., Ferris-Onate, J., Anzar-Bellver, J., Aragones-Beltran, P., & Poveda-Bautista, R. 2008. Farmland appraisal based on the analytic network Process, Journal of Global Optimization. 42: 143-155.
-          Mikhailov, L., Singh M.G. Fuzzy analytic network process and its application to the development of decision support systems. IEEE Trans Syst Man Cybern Syst, Part C (Applications and Reviews) 2003; 33(1): pp. 33-41.
-          Monavvarian, A., Fathi, M.R., Zarchi, M.K., & Faghih, A. 2011. Combining ANP with TOPSIS in selecting Knowledge management strategies (case study: Pars Tire Company). European journal of scientific research, European journal of scientific research.
-          Mugerauer, B. 2010. Eco-city Planning Policies, Practice and Design. Springer Science Business Media B.V. 978-94-007-0383-4.
-          Williams, K., Jenks, M., & Burton, E. 2000. Achieving sustainable urban form. Taylor & Francis.
-          Wu, J. 2014. Urban ecology and sustainability: The state-of-the-science and future directions. Landscape and Urban Planning, 125: pp. 209-221.
-          Xinting, C. 2012. Bilateral Collaborations in Sino-foreign Eco-cities, Master Thesis, Faculty of Technology, policy and management, Dr. Ellen van Bueren.
-          Yang, Z. 2012. Eco-cities: a planning guide. CRC Press, Boca Roton- FL 33487-2742.
-          Yangfan Li, Yi Li, Hu Zhang, Yong Liu, WenwenXu, Xiaodong Z. 2011. Canadian experience in low carbon eco-city development and the implications for China, Energy Procedia, Volume 5, Pages 1791-1795.
-          Zhou, N. 2014. An international review of eco-city theory, indicators, and case studies.