ISSN: 2717-4417

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Associate Professor Of Urban Design in University of Hamadan Bu-Ali Sina University, Faculty of Art and Architecture, Hamadan, Iran

2 Department of Urban Planning, Faculty of Art and Architecture, Bu-Ali Sina University, Hamedan, Iran

10.22034/urbs.2026.146556.5325

Abstract

The city of Hamadan, as one of the key capitals of the Iraqi Seljuqs, experienced a distinct pattern of urban transformation compared to other cities during the Safavid period. Unlike Tabriz, Qazvin, and Isfahan—which underwent major structural changes at that time—Hamadan, due to its border location and ongoing conflicts with the Ottoman Empire, was largely left out of the morphological layering that characterized the Safavid era. This morphological absence—which in the present study we refer to as a "dropping out"—forms the central question of our research: Had Hamadan experienced systematic urban development during the Safavid period, what would its spatial organization have looked like? To answer this, the study adopts a mixed-methods approach, bringing together three theoretical tools—urban palimpsest, literary cartography, and counterfactual analysis—into a single methodological synthesis, and draws on the spatial patterns of Safavid reference cities (Tabriz, Qazvin, and Isfahan) to reconstruct a possible spatial organization for Hamadan. The research methodology is organized in four main steps: layered anatomy and spatial data extraction through the hypothetical removal of Qajar-era elements and reverse-coding of the narrative onto the historical novel Tarikh-e Ghayrat; identification of gaps via a comparative analysis of morphological characteristics across the Seljuq-Ilkhanid, Safavid, and Qajar periods; conceptual reconstruction based on Safavid urban planning principles; and evaluation through a comparison of the proposed model with the existing condition. The findings clarify the nature and causes of the "Safavid layer dropout" in Hamadan, and among several hypothetical reconstruction scenarios, introduce the most plausible one through analytical reasoning. This research offers contributions at three levels—theoretical, methodological, and empirical—and while filling a gap in Iran's historical urban studies, it also proposes a novel methodology for analyzing cities that have not undergone certain period-specific transformations. The contributions are presented on three fronts: theoretical (conceptualizing "dropping out" in urban morphology), methodological (synthesizing urban palimpsest, literary cartography, and counterfactual analysis), and empirical (the first "possible map" of a historical city in Iran).

Keywords

Main Subjects