ISSN: 2717-4417

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Ph.D. in Urban Planning, Faculty of Architecture and Art, University of Guilan, Rasht, Iran

2 Associate Professor, Department of Urban Planning, Faculty of Architecture and Art, University of Guilan, Rasht, Iran

10.22034/urbs.2026.145654.5271

Abstract

1.

Introduction

In recent decades, spatial planning approaches in Iran have increasingly sought to align with international planning paradigms. However, differences between Iran’s socio-cultural context and the institutional and cultural assumptions underlying these frameworks may limit their effectiveness locally. The concept of planning culture (Knieling & Othengrafen, 2015) explains how planning practices are shaped by historically and culturally embedded values, beliefs, norms, and institutional arrangements. Accordingly, effective participatory planning depends not only on formal procedures but also on the acceptance and institutionalization of their underlying values.

Although participation is an established principle in contemporary urban planning, its formal recognition does not necessarily translate into meaningful citizen involvement or influence over decisions. In Tehran, centralized decision-making, hierarchical professional relationships, and limited recognition of citizens’ knowledge and agency highlight the need to examine participation beyond formal mechanisms. This study investigates the formation and reproduction of non-participatory orientations in Tehran’s urban planning environment. It identifies the structural, professional, and cultural conditions shaping planners’ attitudes and develops a context-based theoretical explanation of how participation becomes limited, instrumental, or symbolic. This condition is conceptualized as the infertility of participation.

Methodology

This study adopts a qualitative grounded theory approach to develop a context-sensitive explanation of participation in Tehran’s urban planning environment. This approach enables systematic examination of participants’ experiences and interpretations and facilitates the development of theoretical concepts from empirical data.

The research population included urban planners active in Tehran and individuals with direct experience of participation in urban planning processes. Data were collected through semi-structured, exploratory interviews. Twenty participants were interviewed in 27 sessions, using purposive and snowball sampling to identify information-rich cases.

Data analysis followed Corbin and Strauss’s (2008) grounded theory procedures, with MAXQDA used for data management. Analysis involved iterative coding, constant comparison, and identifying relationships among emerging concepts and categories. Triangulation and intercoder procedures strengthened analytical credibility, while informed consent and ethical considerations were observed. The coding process generated 1,513 initial codes, organized into 29 initial categories and 11 subcategories, subsequently integrated into four main categories forming the empirical basis of the theoretical framework.

Results and Discussion

The analysis identified four main categories: (1) structural foundations shaping attitudes toward participation; (2) professional and academic foundations of planning attitudes; (3) the distinctive planning culture of planners; and (4) the participatory planning environment. The first three explain the conditions reproducing non-participatory orientations, while the fourth identifies the conditions necessary for meaningful participation.

The findings indicate that centralized decision-making, hierarchical institutional relationships, limited local authority, and technocratic approaches constrain decision-making power and citizens’ influence. Professionally and academically, client-oriented practices, excessive reliance on specialized knowledge, resistance to criticism, and limited engagement with local knowledge reinforce non-participatory orientations. Consequently, participation is sometimes interpreted instrumentally, selectively, symbolically, or minimally. It is frequently reduced to consultation, information provision, or citizens’ formal presence rather than enabling them to influence problem definition, alternative selection, and final planning decisions.

The fourth category, the participatory planning environment, comprises four subcategories: participation-supporting structures, a participatory atmosphere, participation-oriented planning, and engaged citizens. These dimensions emphasize institutional commitment, legal foundations, enabling environments, interaction and trust, planners’ facilitative roles, and citizens’ awareness, responsibility, and capacity to make claims. The findings demonstrate that formal mechanisms alone are insufficient; their effectiveness depends on institutional arrangements, professional practices, cultural orientations, and the distribution of authority among planning actors.

The findings also relate to major theoretical approaches to participatory planning. Communicative planning highlights limitations in dialogue, mutual learning, and the influence of citizens’ views. Collaborative planning emphasizes weaknesses in institutional capacity, intermediary structures, and cooperation networks. Agonistic planning addresses the restricted recognition and expression of competing interests, while critical planning theory highlights power relations and institutional inequalities. The findings integrate these perspectives by demonstrating that participation barriers may emerge before formal interaction or negotiation, through institutional and professional orientations that prevent citizens from being recognized as legitimate planning actors.

Based on the relationships among the four categories, the study develops the central concept of infertility of participation. Within this framework, disbelief in participation refers to an attitudinal and institutional mechanism through which participation is undervalued, resisted, or accepted only in limited and instrumental forms. Its interaction with centralized structures, professional norms, planning culture, and unequal power relations produces an environment lacking the capacity to generate, sustain, and institutionalize meaningful participation. Therefore, infertility of participation is not simply the absence of participation or a list of barriers; it describes the interconnected process through which non-participatory orientations and institutional conditions reproduce limited and symbolic participation.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that participation in Tehran’s urban planning environment cannot be explained solely by the presence or absence of formal mechanisms. Rather, it is shaped by structural arrangements, institutional orientations, professional practices, planning culture, and power relations. Its main theoretical contribution is conceptualizing infertility of participation as a condition produced through these interconnected factors. Within this framework, disbelief in participation, combined with centralized decision-making, client-oriented professional practices, technocratic orientations, and limited recognition of citizen agency, sustains non-participatory planning environments.

Transforming participation requires more than changing planners’ attitudes or introducing additional consultation procedures. Although academic and professional education can strengthen participatory orientations and planners’ facilitative roles, these efforts must accompany institutional and structural reforms. These include strengthening legal and organizational foundations, expanding local institutions’ decision-making capacity, recognizing local and experiential knowledge, and creating genuine opportunities for citizens to influence planning decisions. Trust among citizens, planners, and governing institutions is equally important, but depends on the actual distribution of authority, institutional responsiveness, and the demonstrated influence of citizens’ views.

Accordingly, meaningful participation requires simultaneous attention to three dimensions: institutional and structural conditions governing decision-making authority; professional and cultural orientations shaping planners’ understanding of participation; and civic capacities enabling citizens to exercise agency and influence collective decisions. Although structural transformation is gradual and complex, educational interventions, professional capacity-building, stronger local intermediary institutions, and transparent and accountable participatory procedures can help change the conditions reproducing participation infertility. Ultimately, this concept provides a context-based analytical framework for understanding limited, instrumental, and symbolic participation in Tehran’s urban planning environment.

Keywords

Main Subjects